Local government statutory reports
Shetland Islands Council - Statutory follow-up report
18 January 2012 for the Accounts Commission
Shetland Islands Council has made good progress in implementing its improvement plan. It now has many of the building blocks needed to provide Best Value. New political management arrangements and management structures are in place and the council is developing a culture of continuous improvement. However aspects of financial management continue to be of significant concern.
Shetland Islands Council - Statutory follow-up report (PDF | 367 KB)Opens in new window
Shetland Islands Council - Statutory follow-up report (RTF | 202 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Shetland Islands Council (PDF | 163 KB)Opens in new window
Podcast - Shetland Islands Council (MP3 | 1.62MB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport: Progress report - S.R. 2011/3
20 October 2011 for the Accounts Commission
Reviewing an update report on an audit investigation of travel expenses and other matters, the Commission welcomes improvements made by SPT. The regional transport authority has made significant progress against its action plan.
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (PDF | 164 KB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (RTF | 31 KB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport - Appendix (PDF | 116 KB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport - Accounts Commission findings (PDF | 64 KB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport - Accounts Commission findings (RTF | 32 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings - Press release (PDF | 80 KB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport - Podcast (MP3 | 1.57MB)Opens in new window
Aberdeenshire council - S.R. - 2011/2
19 August 2011 for the Accounts Commission
The council took insufficient action to address risks, with delays in implementing actions. It has improved but needs to do more to ensure robust arrangements and oversight and improved quality of service.
Aberdeenshire council (PDF | 394 KB)Opens in new window
Aberdeenshire council (RTF | 218 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings (PDF | 57 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings (RTF | 3 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings - Press release (PDF | 135 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings - Podcast (MP3 | 882 KB)Opens in new window
The Highland Council: Caithness Heat and Power (CHaP): Commission findings and CoA report, 2011
2 March 2011 for the Accounts Commission
The Commission decided that in light of the concerns highlighted in the Controller of Audit’s (CoA) June 2010 statutory report, it required a further report with more evidence. This was considered in February 2011 and the Commission then published its findings.
Commission findings (PDF | 9 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings (RTF | 23 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings - Press release (PDF | 17 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings - Podcast (MP3 | 3.20MB)Opens in new window
CoA follow-up report, February 2011 (PDF | 102 KB)Opens in new window
CoA follow-up report, February 2011 (RTF | 23 KB)Opens in new window
CoA statutory report, June 2010 (PDF | 120 KB)Opens in new window
CoA statutory report, June 2010 (RTF | 259 KB)Opens in new window
CoA statutory report, June 2010 - Press release (PDF | 60 KB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport - S.R. 2010/3
25 November 2010 for the Accounts Commission
There were serious deficiencies in the way that Strathclyde Partnership for Transport managed and controlled travel expenses. However it has taken action since concerns came to light.
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (PDF | 5.37MB)Opens in new window
Strathclyde Partnership for Transport - Accounts Commission findings (PDF | 12 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (PDF | 52 KB)Opens in new window
Podcast - Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (MP3 | 4.33MB)Opens in new window
Shetland Islands Council: Commission findings and CoA report, 2010
16 August 2010 for the Accounts Commission
The Commission decided that in light of the concerns highlighted in the Controller of Audit’s May 2010 statutory report it would hold a Hearing to gather more evidence. This took place on 28 and 29 June. The Commission then published its findings.
Commission findings (PDF | 110 KB)Opens in new window
Commission findings - Press release (PDF | 73 KB)Opens in new window
Hearing transcript - Day 1 (PDF | 1.17MB)Opens in new window
Hearing transcript - Day 2 (PDF | 826 KB)Opens in new window
CoA statutory report, May 2010 (PDF | 42 KB)Opens in new window
CoA statutory report - Press release (PDF | 17 KB)Opens in new window
Podcast summary (MP3 | 8.20MB)Opens in new window
Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2008/09
9 December 2009 for the Accounts Commission
A report by the Controller of Audit to the Accounts Commission under Section 102(1) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973.
Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2008/09 (PDF | 39 KB)Opens in new window
Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2008/09 (RTF | 73 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2008/09 (PDF | 25 KB)Opens in new window
Aberdeen City Council: Annual Audit 2007/08
21 January 2009 for the Accounts Commission
A report by the Controller of Audit to the Accounts Commission under Section 102(1) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973.
Aberdeen City Council: Annual Audit 2007/08 (PDF | 15 KB)Opens in new window
Aberdeen City Council: Annual Audit 2007/08 (RTF | 127 KB)Opens in new window
Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2007/08
21 January 2009 for the Accounts Commission
A report by the Controller of Audit to the Accounts Commission under Section 102(1) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973.
Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2007/08 (PDF | 23 KB)Opens in new window
Shetland Islands Council: Annual Audit 2007/08 (RTF | 165 KB)Opens in new window
Aberdeen City Council: Property sales investigation
30 April 2008 for the Accounts Commission
A report by the Controller of Audit to the Accounts Commission under Section 102(1) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973.
Aberdeen City Council: Property sales investigation (PDF | 49 KB)Opens in new window
Aberdeen City Council: Property sales investigation (RTF | 185 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Aberdeen property sales (PDF | 31 KB)Opens in new window
East Lothian Council: Departmental reorganisation and voluntary redundancy of the Chief Executive
20 June 2007 for the Accounts Commission
A report by the Controller of Audit to the Accounts Commission under Section 102(1) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973.
East Lothian Council (PDF | 167 KB)Opens in new window
East Lothian Council (RTF | 137 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - East Lothian Council (PDF | 32 KB)Opens in new window
Progress report on Scottish Borders Council - S.R. 2002/4 Findings
13 November 2002 for the Accounts Commission
The Accounts Commission for Scotland has issued its findings on the progress made by Borders Council towards rectifying problems which resulted in a £3.9 million overspend in their education service last year. The Commission's findings have been published after the consideration of a progress report by the Controller of Audit, Ronnie Hinds.
Progress report on Scottish Borders Council findings (PDF | 19 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Scottish Borders Council findings (PDF | 18 KB)Opens in new window
Progress report on Scottish Borders Council - S.R. 2002/4
8 November 2002 for the Accounts Commission
The Controller of Audit, Ronnie Hinds has issued a further follow up report on the financial management of education services at Scottish Borders Council. The report has been prepared at the request of the Accounts Commission for Scotland who considered Mr Hinds’ previous report in July 2002.
Progress report on Scottish Borders Council (PDF | 100 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Scottish Borders Council (PDF | 26 KB)Opens in new window
Fife Council: The Third Age Group findings - S.R. 2002/02
14 June 2002 for the Accounts Commission
The Accounts Commission, has considered the issues surrounding Fife Council's financial involvement with the Third Age Group. The Commission accepts the conclusions in the Controller of Audit’s report which provides assurance that grants to the Third Age Group were, in all material respects, used for the purpose intended; identifies procedural short-comings in the Council's financial and other involvement with the Third Age Group; that overall the Council's governance arrangements worked well, and highlights the need for all councils to follow the principles of the Code of Guidance on Following the Public Pound’ in their dealings with arms-length organisations.
Fife Council: Third Age Group findings (PDF | 29 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Fife Council (PDF | 24 KB)Opens in new window
Progress report on Scottish Borders Council - S.R. 2002/03
7 June 2002 for the Accounts Commission
The Controller of Audit, Ronnie Hinds, has issued his follow up report on the financial management of education services at Scottish Borders Council. The report has been prepared at the request of the Accounts Commission for Scotland who considered Mr Hinds’ initial report in November 2001. The report will now be considered by the Accounts Commission.
Fife Council The Third Age Group - S.R. 2002/2
3 May 2002 for the Accounts Commission
Given the level of public interest in Fife Council's financial involvement with the Third Age Group the Controller of Audit, Mr Ronnie Hinds, has prepared an independent report to the Accounts Commission. Mr Hinds' report draws on the findings of a report by the Councils' external auditors and highlights significant issues arising from the Councils dealings with the Third Age Group.
Fife Council The Third Age Group (PDF | 79 KB)Opens in new window
Press release - Fife Council The Third Age Group (PDF | 23 KB)Opens in new window
Accounts Commission's findings on education department overspend at Scottish Borders Council
9 October 2001 for the Accounts Commission
This report by the Controller of Audit, Ronnie Hinds, into the overspend at Scottish Borders Council has found seriousweaknesses in the financial management of education services within the council.
The Accounts Commission for Scotland has issued findings following consideration of a statutory report from the Controller of Audit into the £3.9 million overspend by Scottish Borders Council and the Council's response to that report. In its findings the Commission highlights a number of high-level failings which were the root cause of the problem.
Scottish Borders Council (PDF | 238 KB)Opens in new window
Scottish Borders Council findings (PDF | 64 KB)Opens in new window
Progress report on Inverclyde Council - S.R. 2001/3
18 June 2001 for the Accounts Commission
The Accounts Commission has welcomed evidence of a significant improvement in financial management at Inverclyde Council. This report to the Commission by the Controller of Audit, Ronnie Hinds, finds that the Council is addressing the main areas of concern identified in earlier statutory reports. These included weaknesses in basic financial controls, such as bank reconciliations.
Progress report on Inverclyde Council - SR 2001/1
2 February 2001 for the Accounts Commission
The Controller of Audit reports to the Accounts Commission on the progress made to date by Inverclyde Council in improving its financial procedures. While good progress has been achieved key issues have yet to be fully addressed.
Dumfries and Galloway Council externalisation of residential homes for older people SR 2000/05
17 August 2000 for the Accounts Commission
Dumfries and Galloway Council followed proper tendering processes for transferring the running of its residential homes for older people to the private sector, but there were other aspects of the Council’s procedures where better practice could have been followed, according to a report by the Controller of Audit, Mr Harris Wells, to the Accounts Commission.
Comments on Inverclyde Council's formal response to statutory report 2000/2
1 August 2000 for the Accounts Commission
The Controller of Audit comments on Inverclyde Council's formal response to statutory report 2000/02.
North Lanarkshire Council review of performance of building and roads DLO 1998/99 - S.R. 99/9
15 November 1999 for the Accounts Commission
This report has been produced in response to a request from the Commission following their consideration of the Controller's statutory report on the 1997/98 deficit incurred by this DLO. The audited deficit in 1997/98 for this DLO was £4.5 million. The current report from the Controller shows a much improved position in 1998/99 with the deficit reduced to £0.74 million.
East Ayrshire Council review of Performance of building and works DLO 1998/99 - S.R. 99/10
5 November 1999 for the Accounts Commission
This report has been produced in response to a request from the Commission following their consideration of the Controller's statutory report on the 1997/98 deficit incurred by this DLO. The audited deficit in 1997/98 for this DLO was £1.2 million. The current report from the Controller shows a much-improved position in 1998/99 with the deficit reduced to £517,000.
The 1996/97 and 1997/98 Audits of Grampian Fire Board - S.R. 99/04
30 July 1999 for the Accounts Commission
A report on the 1996/97 and 1997/98 audits of Grampian Fire Board was issued on 16 July by the Controller of Audit, Mr Robert Black. Mr Black reports on the significant financial difficulties which the Grampian Fire Board faced in its first two years, identifies the factors which gave rise to these problems and records the remedial action taken by the Board to strengthen its financial management control.
Shetland Islands Council Termination of the Employment of the Chief Executive - S.R. 99/5
29 July 1999 for the Accounts Commission
A Statutory Report on the termination of the employment of the former Chief Executive of Shetland Islands Council, Mr Nick Reiter, is issued by the Controller of Audit, Mr Robert Black. The decision to terminate Mr Reiter's employment led to significant public expenditure in the form of compensation paid to the Chief Executive and expenses associated with the action taken by the Council. The Report describes the circumstances surrounding the decision to terminate Mr Reiter’s employment and the processes which led up to it.
Millennium Countdown - Year 2000 Compliance - S.R. 99/2
29 May 1999 for the Accounts Commission
Most councils are making good progress in identifying potential problems and finding solutions for them, to ensure there is no major disruption of essential services at the Millennium. However the progress made to date by a few councils is inadequate and positive action needs to be taken by them to accelerate their preparations. These are the main findings of a Statutory Report issued by the independent Accounts Commission.


